This is a difficult question to answer, as the Miss Universe Contest has not been held since this time. However, we can likely say that either Denise Quiñones of Puerto Rico or Lara Dutta of India would have won the title.
As you may know, there is a new Miss Universe contest every year and it's usually held in December of each year. The last Miss Universe contest was in 2000 where there were 54 contestants from around the world. It was supposed to be 55 but one contestant from Guyana competed as an individual instead of with her country’s national pageant.
In 2000 year, the lady who was fortunate to become the miss universe title is Lara Dutta. She is the 49th Miss Universe pageant. She has become miss universe on 12th May, 2000 at the Eleftheria Indoor Hall in Nicosia, cyprus. It was the piece of honour that at second times someone from India has become miss universe. After in 1994, Lara dutta has become the second miss universe again in 2000.