How many cultures have been destroyed by Islam and Christianity?

There is no credible historical number for how many cultures were “destroyed” by Islam or Christianity. Across roughly 2,000 years of Christian history and 1,400 years of Islamic history, both religions spread across many societies, but the outcomes ranged from violent suppression and forced conversion to peaceful conversion, coexistence, cultural blending and the creation of entirely new cultures.

So a claim such as “Christianity destroyed X cultures and Islam destroyed Y” would be historically misleading.

From my perspective, this topic becomes much clearer when we separate religion from empire, warfare and politics. Religion certainly played a role in some episodes of cultural suppression, but saying religion alone destroyed entire cultures oversimplifies centuries of history.

Why It Can't Be Counted

Historians don't have a standard definition of a “destroyed culture.”

Consider what could qualify:

Cultures also aren't fixed objects. Languages, beliefs, food, clothing, political systems and traditions continuously change.

That's why I wouldn't trust any viral post giving an exact number.

Christian Expansion

Christianity initially spread within the Roman Empire and later became closely connected with European kingdoms and empires.

Centuries later, European colonial expansion carried Christianity into the Americas, Africa, Asia and Oceania.

In some colonial settings, missionaries contributed to education, literacy and the preservation of local languages. In others, Christianization accompanied policies that suppressed Indigenous religions, ceremonies and institutions.

The important point is that “Christian expansion” covers dramatically different historical experiences.

Islamic Expansion

Islam emerged in Arabia during the 7th century and expanded rapidly into the Middle East, North Africa, and beyond through conquest, trade, migration and missionary activity.

Yet conquered populations did not universally convert immediately.

Islamic societies also absorbed major influences from Persian, Byzantine, Indian, Greek and other traditions. Rather than simply erasing everything that existed before, this interaction helped produce distinctive Islamic cultures in places ranging from Persia to Spain and South Asia.

The Alhambra in Spain is a visible reminder of how Islamic civilization itself produced enduring cultural traditions.

Destruction vs. Transformation

This distinction matters a lot.

If people adopt a different religion but retain their language, food, literature and local customs, saying their culture was completely “destroyed” doesn't really work.

Often cultures became hybrid.

Persian culture, for instance, survived the Islamic conquest and subsequently became enormously influential within the wider Islamic world.

Similarly, Christianity developed very different cultural expressions in Ethiopia, Armenia, Europe, India and Latin America.

Personally, I find “transformation” a much more useful concept than automatically assuming cultural replacement.

Role of Empire & Politics

Some of the worst historical examples of cultural suppression happened when religious authority became intertwined with political power.

Conquest could involve destruction of religious sites, restrictions on traditional practices, forced assimilation, discriminatory laws or conversion pressures.

But empires also conquered people belonging to the same religion, while rulers sometimes protected communities belonging to different religions.

So the equation:

Religion → conquest → culture disappears

is simply too neat for actual history.

I'd examine each case through religion + political power + economics + warfare + migration + local resistance rather than blaming one factor automatically.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Did Christianity destroy Indigenous cultures?

Christian colonial institutions contributed to severe cultural suppression in some regions, but experiences varied greatly across periods and places.

2. Did Islamic conquests eliminate pre-Islamic cultures?

Some traditions disappeared or changed significantly, while others survived and strongly influenced Islamic civilization.

3. Which religion destroyed more cultures?

There is no credible historical dataset that allows such a numerical comparison.

4. Can conversion happen without cultural destruction?

Yes. Communities frequently adopt religions while retaining or adapting languages, customs and identities.

Must Read: Which is the most popular religion around the globe?