V
Vansh Chopra· 8 years ago
Covering important news, trending stories, and global events with balanced insights and reliable information.

Whom should we believe more , Bhagavad Gita or Science ?

0
955

Join this conversation

Sort By

Choosing between the Bhagavad Gita and science is like choosing between a compass and a map. They do not contradict each other; rather, they operate in entirely different realms of human experience and inquiry.

1. The Realm of Science (The "How")

Science is a systematic tool used to understand the physical, empirical world. It relies on observation, experimentation, data, and logical testing.

  • Purpose: It explains how the universe works—from the behavior of subatomic particles to the expansion of galaxies.
  • Approach: It is constantly evolving. When new evidence comes to light, scientific theories change to reflect the truth.
  • Limitation: Science is excellent at telling us what is, but it generally cannot tell us what ought to be. It struggles to provide objective answers to questions about morality, emotional purpose, or the meaning of life.

2. The Realm of the Bhagavad Gita (The "Why")

The Bhagavad Gita is a philosophical and spiritual text that addresses the internal world—the human mind, ethics, and consciousness.

  • Purpose: It explains why we should act and how we should manage our internal state. It focuses on duty (Dharma), selflessness (Nishkama Karma), resilience, and inner peace.
  • Approach: It provides a psychological and philosophical framework to help individuals navigate grief, anxiety, moral dilemmas, and existential crises.
  • Limitation: It is not a textbook for physics, chemistry, or biology, and treating it as a literal scientific manual misses its deeper allegorical and philosophical value.

How They Can Coexist

Instead of looking at them as rivals, many modern thinkers view them as complementary disciplines:

FeatureScienceBhagavad Gita
DomainThe External/Physical WorldThe Internal/Spiritual World
ObjectiveSeeking empirical truth and innovationSeeking mental equilibrium and moral clarity
Core Question"How does this function?""How should I live my life?"
MethodObservation, math, and experimentationContemplation, duty, and self-awareness

For example, science can teach you how to build incredible technologies, but it cannot teach you the ethics required to use them safely. The Bhagavad Gita can teach you how to remain calm under pressure and act without selfish greed, which can actually make you a better, more focused scientist, professional, or student.


Which should you believe more?

You do not have to choose one over the other.

  • Use science to make logical, evidence-based decisions about your health, technology, career, and understanding of the physical world.
  • Turn to the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita when you need emotional resilience, moral guidance, purpose, and a mindset to handle life's inevitable ups and downs.

Believing in science gives you a sharp mind, while understanding spiritual philosophy gives you a grounded heart. A balanced life relies on both.

Answered by
P
Pari DeshmukhReporting what matters — with 12 years of ground-level journalism behind every story.
View Profile

Pari Deshmukh is a journalist with over 12 years of experience covering current affairs across print and digital media in India. She holds a Master's degree in Journalism and Mass Communication from Pune University, bringing both academic grounding and extensive field experience to her reporting. Over her career, Pari has reported on national politics, policy developments, social issues, and breaking news events across India. Her work has appeared on platforms including The Print, Scroll.in, and Hindustan Times Digital, where she has built a reputation for factual, balanced, and timely reporting on stories that shape public discourse. With 12+ years in the field, she has covered major national events, conducted ground-level investigations, and interviewed policymakers, civil society leaders, and public figures. Her journalism is driven by one standard — verified facts reported without distortion, regardless of the pressure or pace of the news cycle. She has participated in press panels at the Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards and is a member of the Press Club of India. Her reporting continues to serve readers who need current affairs coverage they can trust.

Updated on05/21/26
0

1345-1766741142880-8251

The words in Bhagavad Gita are so intricately used with flexible meanings that different people often interpret it differently.

It says, "Karmany evadhikaras te ma phalesu kadachana ma karma-phala-hetur bhur ma te sango 'stv akarmani"…

It means you should keep on working without expecting any result. However, this isn’t necessarily meant to be taken literally or in every situation.

What it means is that we shouldn’t act greedily and selfishly. We should always be selfless when helping others, when doing something good. Because when we expect something from our good, we actually spoil that “good”—we take away its essence. It’s like we’re doing something for someone, not exactly to help, but to get greater rewards in return.

While this in itself isn’t a bad thing today if it’s getting people to do something good, according to Hindu scriptures (and other religions) it’s something not acceptable. You must keep doing good without hoping anything in return—this will surprinsgly bring good to you.

On the other hand, science doesn’t say we shouldn’t do this. It doesn’t say anything that’s contrary to Bhagavad Gita. It’s just how we try to interpret it.

Science says we must always keep an eye on our goals—where we want to go so that we don’t get lost amid all the distractions. It asks us to vision the end result every day in terms of measuring success—to motivate us. Because when we’re focusing on the end goal, we would eventually achieve that despite all the struggles.

It all depends on how you interpret Bhagavad Gita and how you use scientific theories. They don’t fit in every aspect of life. You need to know where they are more suitable.

Answered by
K
View Profile
Updated on12/26/25
0