Go for these:
- Personalized photo frames or memory albums showing your best moments together are always hits.
- Handmade scrapbooks with memories, inside jokes, and love notes.
- DIY candles in their favorite scents.
- Knitted scarves or blankets if you have those skills.
- Customized mug with your photo and quotes.
- Homemade cake or cookies in their favorite flavor with decorative icing.
- Photo collage or canvas painting of you both.
- Handwritten letter or poem expressing your feelings.
- Personalized playlist burned on a CD with your songs.
- Decorated box filled with small gifts like chocolates and handwritten notes.
- Baked brownies or fudge in a cute jar.
- Coupon book offering free hugs, movie nights, massages etc.
The key is putting thought and effort which shows you care way more than expensive bought gifts.