Let's Diskuss
K
Komal Verma· 8 years ago
Covering sports news, analysis, and performance insights with accuracy, clarity, and timely updates.

Should Dhoni Retire and Make Way for Young Players?

0
1.1K

Join this conversation

Sort By
Replying to the question above
Answered on05/12/26

This debate becomes popular almost every IPL season. Many fans believe MS Dhoni should continue because his experience, leadership, and game awareness still help Chennai Super Kings. At the same time, others feel younger players need more opportunities to prepare for the future.

Even in recent matches, Dhoni’s presence creates huge excitement among fans, and stadiums often turn yellow because of him. Cricket experts say retirement should depend on fitness and team strategy rather than age alone. Dhoni himself has repeatedly said he will decide based on how his body responds. Right now, he still plays an important mentoring role, even if he bats lower down the order.

P
Priyaa Agrawal
Author
View Profile
0
Replying to the question above
Answered on05/09/26
 

The question of whether MS Dhoni should retire and make way for younger players is something that has been debated for a long time. But the answer is not simply yes or no, because it depends on his role, fitness, and contribution to the team.

First, Dhoni has already retired from international cricket, so the discussion mainly applies to his role in franchise cricket (IPL). Even there, he has gradually shifted from being a full-time player to more of a mentor, strategist, and guiding leader for younger players. This already shows that transition is happening naturally.

One strong argument for retirement is the need for young players to get opportunities. Every team must build for the future, and that requires giving match experience to new talent. If senior players stay too long in key roles, it can slow down the growth of next-generation cricketers, who need exposure at the top level.

However, there is also a strong argument in favour of Dhoni continuing in some capacity. Even at this stage, his biggest strengths are calm decision-making, match reading ability, and leadership under pressure. These qualities are rare and cannot be easily replaced by young players. In close matches, his experience often helps the team stay stable.

Another important point is that Dhoni is not just a player; he is a mentor figure in the dressing room. Many young cricketers learn from his mindset, discipline, and tactical thinking. His presence alone adds value even if he is not playing every match fully.

At the same time, modern cricket is becoming faster and more physical. Young players bring higher energy, speed, and aggressive style, which is necessary for long-term success. So teams must maintain a balance between experience and youth.

In conclusion, Dhoni should not be forced into retirement, but there should be a gradual transition system where young players are given more responsibility over time. He can continue in a limited playing or mentoring role, helping guide the team while allowing the next generation to grow. His legacy is already complete, and whatever decision he takes should be respected.

 
Don’t miss this trending question everyone is searching for:-  What is Blockchain technology
 
M
Michael Jons
Author
View Profile
0
Replying to the question above
Answered on05/26/20
So , you are the savior battling for youths of sports in India ?

Gracious , are you a similar one who is battling for ladies to get into parliament ?

What I don't comprehend is the reason should somebody get an opportunity by removing the other one who is doing his/her job consummately ? What is in this mentality ?

He is serving his job in Indian cricket crew impeccably and for what reason should he allow to another person ? Straightforward inquiry, for what reason should he ?

It ought to act naturally who should take that choice and on the off chance that he does as such all alone as a result of his compassion for other people, he will get acclaim. It ought to be from his own brain since he is all around fit doing his obligation superbly for the team.Who are we to recommend what he ought to do in his life ?

Despite the fact that he is performing admirably and driving India effectively, wouldn't you say it's treachery to request that he leave the game which he cherishes more than anything in this world and investing a great deal of energy into it. Indian cricket crew needs him and there is no other reasonable substitution for him starting at now . He is sufficiently shrewd and has enough minds to leave the game when he isn't happy with his own exhibition. No requirement for your or my proposals.

A
akash chauhan
Author
View Profile
0
Replying to the question above
Answered on11/24/18
Well !! Well!! Well

I think till 2019 worldcup he shouldn't

I will tell you why-

We don't have wicketkeeper like him (If you will look at shah ,parthiv or kartik) he is the best amongs them.

If you see his fitness level Very few or we can say no one is there who can run like him

And till 2019 worldcup I don't think we can produce a wicketkeeper who can bat like him at no6.

And the experience he has will always help team india.

At the same time you know virat kohli he is bit of aggressive so we need someone to pull virat kohli back and Dhoni can do that.

K
kunal jaiswal
Author
View Profile
0
Related

Why is cricket more popular in India as compared to other sports?

Answered on12/25/17

That’s how it has always been. Like since inception, cricket has been perceived as more appealing than other sports. And with personalities like that of Sunil Gavaskar, Kapil Dev, Azhar, Sehwag, Dravid, Sachin, Dhoni and more, its popularity only spiked high.

As far the other sports are concerned, in recent times, they did have climbed up in the spotlight. Like football, MMA, tennis and even badminton boasts a massive following today. Nothing, however, comparable to cricket.

Media always focus more on cricket. Sponsors always put more money in cricket matches. So people get to hear, see more of cricket. And since more people are watching this sport, more sponsors and media will invest in and talk about it. It’s like a cycle.

But it’s not bad. We shouldn’t be complaining about it. Like in Brazil, Soccer is more popular; in USA, Football (rugby) is at the top; people in Canada obsess Ice Hockey. Every country leans toward particular sport.

All we need is a bit more boost, encouragement and investment in other sports to get the cricket-like cycle started for them.
A
Ajay Paswan
Author
View Profile
3
0
Replying to the question above
Updated on12/29/25

Mahendra Singh Dhoni is the most successful captain of Indian cricket team till date. Crossing one milestone to another, he has taken Indian team to a whole different level on the global map, not just with his incredible captaincy but also as an extraordinary batsman who has an unmatched capability of batting under extreme pressure. 

This alone should be enough to credit this man the right to decide when he should hang his boots. One shouldn’t really force him.

Moving on to the next point. After giving up his captainship to Virat Kohli, Dhoni has been performing even better both in ODI and T20 format. Plus, yes there are many good wicket keepers in line—but they all simply can’t match Dhoni. And not to mention, even when not a captain, Dhoni plays a crucial role for the entire team, with Kohli consulting him on field before making any decision. (We’re all still in awe with his instincts about DRS).

So NO!!!! Even at 36 years, Dhoni is the backbone of the entire team, contributing immensely from every angle. We all should just stop scanning him obsessively on his performance. He’s doing good— just as good as any youngster who would replace him. Plus, the psychological impact he brings on the opponents—a new player can’t do that!

We should let Dhoni decide himself when he wants to retire.

R
Rohit Valiyan
Author
View Profile
0